June 01, 2006

Passports and whining and insults, oh my!

June 1 - Newsbeat1 often posts excerpts from Question Period in the Commons (which is another good reason to visit a couple of times each day) and today's post concerns questions from yesterday as to what the Conservative Government is doing to stop the pending requirement to present passports when entering the U.S. at the northern border.

First I should mention that U.S. tourism has decreased to Canada in the past few years, and provincial and national Liberal politicians and pundits have come up with a variety of explanations: Sept. 11, SARS, the dollar, in short, everything and nothing.

Some, though, have voiced the obvious reasons: Canada was a member of the Axis of Weasels; Chretien flew to Mexico (then a member of the UNSC) to encourage Pres. Fox to vote against U.N. action in Iraq; Canadians seem to love Michael Moore; there's a rather long lists of terrorists are out there with Canadian backgrounds (although some are dead or in Gitmo) yet the prime minister said "there are no terrorists in Canada"; and members of the Liberal Party and the news media persist in insulting us.

Now it escapes me at the moment why Americans might not choose to visit a country that has so much contempt for Americans and furthermore actively campaigned to derail American efforts to deal with a known threat and financial supporter of terrorsts, but the Minister for Public Safety, Stockwell Day, demonstrates considerably more sense on this issue than his predecessors.

Newsbeat 1: Hansard excerpts- Question Period- May 31 ,20060:

Hon. Robert Thibault (West Nova, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, on the issue of the border with the United States, this government has abandoned Canadians. The Maritimes depend on American and Acadian tourism. American families have to spend more than $500—the price of passports—to enter Canada. Americans will avoid the Maritimes, and our tourism industry will suffer further. Canadian exporters who must travel to the United States have the same problem. [Americans will need a passport to enter the U.S., not Canada, although the previous government had threatened to enact such a policy as an act of retribution.]

Why is this government abandoning Canadian communities on the passport issue?

[...]

Will our government not represent us on this vital question or do we have to depend on U.S. governors to defend our interests? This is bush league leadership. Once again, the Prime Minister shows himself to be a shrub, a little bush. (Emphasis added)

Hon. Stockwell Day (Minister of Public Safety, CPC): Mr. Speaker, insults like that created a lot of problems for the Liberal regime.

A number of speakers take to the floor to whine about how passport requirements will hurt tourism and they all take their shots at the U.S. -- although I should note that they do not for its value in the debate but because they think they're ingratiating themselves with Canadians who they fondly imagine like to hear that stuff.

Somehow I doubt passport requirements will radically affect American tourism up here any more such would affect tourism to other countries. A large number of Americans, as do Canadians, hold passports already, but what may be happening is that the Liberals are establishing the grounds for blaming the Tories for reduced American tourism, as though their own big mouths weren't a major factor.

There's a saying about being careful what you wish for. A common Canadian complaint is that Americans don't know anything about them, but Americans have become more acutely aware of the world since Sept. 11 and, I fear, of Canada -- or maybe I should say the version of Canada the news media up here likes to project.

Posted by: Debbye at 08:48 AM | Comments (3) | Add Comment
Post contains 594 words, total size 4 kb.

1 IMO, the main reason for a decrease in tourist visits from the U.S. is the dollar. Unless you continually price cross border items out, it’s hard to get a grasp of the magnitude of this swing. Mostly as a matter of curiosity I check Yachtworld (www.yachtworld.com) for used boats and pricing trends (who knows - one day I may buy). This is a worldwide database of brokers but most searches return North American boats. I have watched Canadian dollar prices drop dramatically for U.S. based boats over the past few years – several years ago I only searched the U.S. market out of curiosity, most boats were too expensive and were priced the same in Ontario. Now if I were actively buying, I would most certainly look in the nearby U.S. market. I recently checked out a Cannondale bike (made in the U.S.) at Sporting Life. I bought a Cannondale road bike from them six years ago – I was astounded at the drop in price for the high-end road bikes. The top of the line R5000 used to be over $4,000, now Sporting life is selling it for $2,900. Same specs and high-end components. Now turn around and look at it the other way, Canada used to be a bargain for Americans, just imagine the “sticker shock” tourists must get.

Posted by: John B at June 01, 2006 09:02 AM (3RGzm)

2 Not to mention the lack of selection, the higher price of everything (exceeding the exchange rate), and the privilege of paying 15% tax on everything you buy.

Posted by: Larry Borsato at June 01, 2006 12:11 PM (UOxU4)

3 The higher dollar could be a factor now, but it wasn't in 2002 and (I believe) 2003. Sorry. Just think "France."

Posted by: Debbye at June 03, 2006 07:17 AM (wa1UQ)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
17kb generated in CPU 0.0118, elapsed 0.0845 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.0778 seconds, 145 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.