February 20, 2006

Cdn. Journalists say publish cartoons

Feb. 20 - A bit of vindication for Ezra Levant and the Western Standard: according to a recent Compass poll, about 6 in 10 Canadian journalists say Publish cartoons.

Interesting breakdown of options:

According to Monday's report, about 17 per cent of those polled felt all major Canadian media should have reprinted the images. Another 18 per cent said most media should have carried the cartoons and 25 per cent said at least some of Canada's biggest outlets should have used the caricatures.

By contrast, about 31 per cent of respondents said major media were correct in the decision not to use the material.

The great divide:
Of those who supported non-publication, most cited respect as the reason.

The bulk of those who said the cartoons should have been carried said fear was the primary motivator for not publishing.

Encouragingly, the poll also found that the journalists who participated understood the implications of not publishing the cartoons:
Still, the majority of Canadian journalists also said they had at least some concern that not publishing the cartoons increased the power of extremist groups at the expense of Shia Muslims who include portraits in their every day lives and pluralist Muslims who want the Islamic world to accept diversity of opinion.

Journalists were asked to score how strongly they agree with that argument on a scale of one to five, with five being the strongest point of agreement. A total of 62 per cent scored three or more on the scale.

(Via Neale News.)

Posted by: Debbye at 04:52 PM | Comments (4) | Add Comment
Post contains 257 words, total size 2 kb.

1 Publishing is simply foolish in this time window. The possible effects of publishing are known. Common sense would dictate that this one cartoon topic can be allowed to rest for the moment. There is no risk of losing any freedom of speech. It is simply a matter of not feeding the obvious Jihadist plot for wild disruption in the streets. The disruption that contibutes to damaging the advancment of peace and democracy in Iraq and Afghanistan. The same disruption that has been so effective thwarting peace around Israel and advancing the Hamas. More troops and fewer cartoons will help with security for those who risked their lives to vote in Iraq and Afghanistan. TG

Posted by: TonyGuitar at February 21, 2006 02:44 PM (rmMzv)

2 I disagree with you, Tony. When fear and intimidation dictate what we read and discuss then we have lost our freedom to express our thoughts. We don't always get to choose where we make our stand. If it is over some cartoons we may wish it was something more, um, noble and high-minded that we need to defend, but that doesn't take us off the hook.

Posted by: Debbye at February 21, 2006 04:58 PM (qePxg)

3 The newspapers say that publishing the cartoons will serve no useful purpose, and that those who really want to see the cartoons can do so on the Internet. Fine. I'll go to the internet to see the cartoons, and then I'll stay on the internet for the rest of my information acquisition. Newspaper readership and advertising revenue is collapsing so fast that many of the political correctors employed there will lose their jobs before they get to retirement. It couldn't happen to a nicer bunch.

Posted by: CJ at February 21, 2006 06:54 PM (fuUoQ)

4 Debbye, we shall see over time where the the gains or losses due to publishing cartoons pan out. Cartoons at the moment are a fuel for the disruption of infant democracies beginning to take hold in Afghanistan and Iraq. There is no threat to our freedom of speech and only a temporary restraint on the one topic of Muhammed characture. We can afford to ease up on the one topic at least until Muslims adjust to the freedom of democracy and understand free speech better. In the mean time, this whole exercise is a diversion. We should be supporting those who risked their lives to vote with more troops to provide more security. It will be expensive, but to do less is unthinkable. TG

Posted by: TonyGuitar at February 22, 2006 04:04 AM (rmMzv)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
16kb generated in CPU 0.0126, elapsed 0.0899 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.0826 seconds, 146 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.