June 18, 2005

Explaining oneself

June 18 - Ex-pat Yank Robert Tumminello has written about the experience of living abroad during and after Sept. 11 and the accumulation of events that led to his becoming a blogger:

Yet what was also troubling was how so many in the British mass media were becoming increasingly at ease with "intellectuals", "scholars" and "activists" who possessed what can only be described as "interesting" takes on American policy and just about anything to do with Americans as people. Indeed, nothing was off limits: Americans are fat; they are idiots; they are racists; they are gun-lovers; they are hypocrites; they hate Muslims; they drive cars; the drive SUVs; they are Christians (oh, the horrors that some actually are Christians!). You name it. Of course, if an American so much as quietly mumbled "boo" about disagreeing with someone who thinks it's approved by a holy book to crash a hijacked plane suicidally into a building, he is deemed to be "intolerant".

There we were. Although the attitude was not universal of course, while in the U.S. during September and October 2001, as Americans tried to figure out what to do next and worried about what further attacks might be in the pipeline, in too much British and other media, Americans were simultaneously ceasing to be "people". Instead, Americans were more than ever before just human representatives of some Zionist-defending (or, just replace "Zionist" with a three letter word starting with "J"), environment rubbishing, globe-gobbling, imperialist corporate state. I also found increasingly that a large segment of the population here really did have no clue about America other than what they see and hear in that media. That is not a criticism; it's just a fact: Americans are, somehow, "a quick read"; everyone else in the world is, of course, "complex".

What the? Looking for somewhere sanity might be found (it sure wasn't in most newspapers, on radio, or TV), I retreated to the net. (Amazing that sentence, isn't it? Looking for sanity on the internet?)

I found this to be an absorbing read because it recounts a journey back to the common, American denominator without being maudlin or bitter.

Many of us have been surprised to find ourselves agreeing with the Republicans on a number of issues, and I think Robert summed up the reason:

While not a "conservative" technically, I believed -- and still do -- that we as Americans are all united by one thing: While we might argue over "policy A" or "policy B", overall America and democracy and freedom are worth defending. Period.

And I found that conservatives, far more than my liberal friends and increasingly even moderate Democrats, seemed to better understand that.

I don't recall "America, democracy and freedom are worth defending" being on the list when exit polls were conducted in the 2004 presidential election, and the fact that it wasn't reflects indicates just how out of touch pollsters are with those they presume to analyze and "explain."

If the American media and pollsters are that disconected with Americans, how can foreign media not amplify that disconnect?

Posted by: Debbye at 07:42 AM | Comments (1) | Add Comment
Post contains 513 words, total size 3 kb.

1 Excellent read. The reasons he mentions are the reasons why I'm a conservative as well. The difference between Americans and Canadians is that Americans seem to me to be American first and hyphenated Americans second. In Canada the reverse seems to be true. Those are the dangers of the great multi-national myth. Witness what is going on across much or Europe right now. There will be a huge backlash in both America and Canada soon. America first and then Canada will follow, as they always do. But there will have to be a change in government here first. Don't forget though that almost half of Americans don't think like this. That's a little unsettling to me.

Posted by: John Crittenden at June 18, 2005 12:29 PM (cONYb)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
15kb generated in CPU 0.091, elapsed 0.3419 seconds.
64 queries taking 0.3276 seconds, 143 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.